First Base Mitt
Rawlings PRODCT
The DCT is ranked #1 because of its versatility. I absolutely love this mitt and to top it off it can be worn pretty much any way you want. A ton of other companies base their first base mitts off of this one here.
Cost: $300
Break In: Normal
Durability: Great (don't get R2G)
Pros: One Hinge or Two Hinge, Great Laces, Massive Pocket, Durable
Cons: Might feel big for small hands
Middle Infield 2 Hinge
Rawlings PRO200
Sturdy and durable leather with a deep pocket. PRO200's have a square like shape between the thumb, heel and pinky.
Cost: $299.95
Break-In: Medium-Hard
Durability: Tank (UNLESS R2G)
Pros: Great Laces, Wide/Open Palm, One Hinge or Two Hinge
Cons: Wide Finger Stalls Bad For Small Hands, Too Deep For 1 Hinge
Cons: Wide Finger Stalls Bad For Small Hands
MID INFIELD 11.5"
Wilson 1786
I'd say the 1786 is the most universal pattern for infielders. The Glove has a more round shape with a medium pocket. (spin control is mental more than anything, get one without it if you don't like the look)
Cost: $399.95
Break-In: Normal Difficulty
Durability: Good
Pros: Great Shape, One Hinge or Two, Fits Small Hands Well
Cons: Large Hands Take Longer to Fit Comfortably, Laces Could Be Better
Third Base Small to Average size
Wilson 1787 11.75"
This is the same as the Matt Chapman model which is my go-to for 3rd right now. It has a deep pocket and a round shape.
Cost:$399.95
Break-In: Normal Difficulty
Durability: Good
Pros: Great Shape, One Hinge or Two Hinge, Fits Small Hands Well
Cons: Takes Large Hands Longer to Fit Comfortably, Laces Could Be Better
Third Base Size Large
Rawlings KB17 12.25"
This is the same as the Matt Chapman model which is my go-to for 3rd right now. It has a deep pocket and a round shape.
Cost:$399.95
Break-In: Normal Difficulty
Durability: Good
Pros: Great Shape, One Hinge or Two Hinge, Fits Small Hands Well
Cons: Takes Large Hands Longer to Fit Comfortably, Laces Could Be Better
Outfield
Rawlings PROBH3 13"
Deep pocket and as much length as you can legally have in baseball. With that being said it's somewhat heavy. Side note: Hand sewn welting makes it a little more comfortable.
Cost: $299.95
Break-In: Hard
Durability: Great
Pros: Great Lacing, Hand Sewn Welting, Most Length Possible, Great For 2 In Pinky
Cons: Heavy ish, Wider Finger Stalls For Small Hands, Not The Best For Traditional Break-In
Outfield
Emery Cordura 12.75"
Deep Pocket with even close . Can be worn Trad or Two in the Pink. This glove is incredibly light... cannot stress that enough. If you want a slightly softer leather get this blonde leather model. If you want a stiffer leather go with the black leather from Emery.
Cost: $299.95
Break-In: Average - Hard
Durability: Good
Pros: Very Light Weight, Trad + TIP Friendly
Cons: Cordura Is Not Super Comfortable When Finger Is Out
Catchers Mitt Flat Break In (1 Hinge)
All Star Pro Elite
Pick whatever size you want but the Pro Elite is my go to right now for a flat style break in. Plus a small bonus is that it has great pop.
Cost: $449.95
Break In: Hard
Durability: Solid (just barely under good)
Pros: Glove Pops, Lots Of Feel For Ball
Cons: Bad Stingers, Whiplash Effect When Ball Hits The Web, Very Expensive
Catchers Mitt BOX BREAK IN (2 Hinge)
Rawlings PROCM33
This is the go to for a box break in and will work for a traditional or a shifted grip. Deep pocket especially when you encourage the box break in. Average weight for a catchers mitt and deals with stingers pretty well.
Cost: $299.95
Break In: Normal (For Catchers)
Durability: Good
Pros: Adapts To Any Break In Style, Durable, Deep Pocket + Good Feel For Ball
Cons: N/A
Best Budget Glove Series
Rawlings Gamer XLE (Series)
The Gamer XLE is HANDS DOWN the best glove at $150. This series compares to gloves priced $250+. It has a thicker feel to it which helps with its durability as well. Very little down sides to this glove, especially considering its price.
Cost: $150
Break In: Normal Compared To Gloves $250 +
Durability: Great
Pros: Great Laces, Solid Internals/ Construction, High Quality Feel at Low Cost
Cons: Sweat Builds Up On Speed Shell Material
Best Budget Glove Series
Wilson A1000 (Series)
The A1000 is best fit for someone wanting softer leather while maintaining some durability. These are pretty comfortable and can be gamed pretty quickly after getting it.
Cost: $150
Break In: Easy/ Just Play Catch
Durability: Solid but will thin out and soften with lots of use
Pros: Sticks The Ball, User Friendly Shape
Cons: Leather Is Very Wrinkly (cosmetic issue)
Best Budget Glove Series
Mizuno MVP Prime (Series)
The MVP Prime is our top pick for most value at the lowest price. Whether your a kid needing a gamer, a dad trying to play catch or not wanting to drop $400 on a slow pitch glove... the MVP Prime Series will get her done.
Cost: $120
Break In: Easy/ Just Play Catch
Durability: Good.... for price
Pros: Quick Break In, Light Weight, Solid Laces
Cons: A Lot of Flex/ Stretch While Catching Due To Cheaper Leather